Good Luck Timbers

Reclaimed vs. New Wood: Which One Is Right for Your Project ?

When starting a furniture, flooring, or renovation project, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is choosing the right type of wood. Should you go with reclaimed timber, rich in character and history, or opt for new wood, prized for its consistency and fresh look?

In this guide, we break down the pros and cons of each option to help you make an informed choice—whether you’re a homeowner, architect, designer, or contractor.

comparision between old and new woods

What Is Reclaimed Wood?

Reclaimed wood is timber salvaged from old buildings, bridges, ships, and other structures. At Good Luck Timbers, our reclaimed collection includes Burma Teak, CP Teak, and Madras Burma Teak, carefully sourced and processed to preserve their unique qualities.

Because reclaimed wood has been aged naturally over decades, it often boasts a denser structure, exceptional stability, and a distinctive patina that can’t be replicated in newly milled timber.

What Is New Wood?

New wood is freshly harvested from sustainable forests, then cut and processed for a wide range of applications.

We offer high-quality new woods like Rosewood, Sal Wood, Pine, American Walnut, Beech, White Oak, and White Ash—each selected for its durability and natural beauty.

New timber provides consistent sizing, uniform grains, and greater flexibility in finishing options.

Reclaimed Wood – Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Environmentally Sustainable: By repurposing existing timber, you reduce waste and preserve forests.

  • Unique History & Character: Every plank carries a story, adding warmth and authenticity to your space.

  • Naturally Seasoned: Decades of natural drying make reclaimed wood more stable and resistant to warping.

Cons:

  • Limited Sizing: Sizes can be irregular or unavailable in large dimensions.

  • Higher Cost: Sourcing, cleaning, and processing reclaimed timber often increase the price.

  • More Preparation Needed: May require additional treatment to remove nails, residues, or surface imperfections.

New Wood – Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Consistent Supply & Sizes: Easier to match planks for big projects.

  • Smooth Finishes: Great for modern designs needing clean lines and uniform color.

  • Often More Affordable: Especially for common species and standard sizes.

Cons:

  • Less Character: Lacks the aged appearance and unique patina of reclaimed wood.

  • Requires Drying: Needs proper seasoning to avoid shrinking or warping.

  • Less Eco-Friendly: Unless sourced from certified sustainable plantations.

Which Wood Should You Choose?

Your choice depends on your project goals, budget, and style preference:

Choose reclaimed wood if you want:

  • Timeless character and history

  • Stronger, more stable timber

  • A sustainable, eco-friendly option

Choose new wood if you prefer:

  • Uniform sizing and consistent appearance

  • Lower costs for large projects

  • Contemporary, modern designs

Final Thoughts

Both reclaimed and new wood have distinct advantages. Whether you’re restoring a heritage home, designing a modern interior, or building custom furniture, selecting the right timber is essential for lasting quality and beauty.

At Good Luck Timbers, we specialize in both reclaimed and new timber—carefully processed and quality-checked—so you can create spaces you’re proud of.

Need Help Choosing the Right Timber?

Contact us today or Request a Quote and let our experienced team guide you every step of the way.

Scroll to Top